Publication ethics
Publication and Misconduct Ethics Statement:

Publication in the journal requires the responsibility and cooperation of all concerned parties (authors, reviewers, editor-in-chief, editors, and members of the editorial board). The Editor-in-Chief and Editors are responsible for maintaining and monitoring publishing ethics and maintaining the academic record. The editorial board is responsible for verifying articles that contain fraudulent statements or plagiarism. The Editorial Board's goal is to maintain publication at the highest publishing standards, which means: good quality, original, research-based articles, but also corrections, clarifications, retractions and apologies, if necessary. We value the contributions of everyone involved in the work we publish.


Publication and authorship:

* All submitted research is subject to a strict review process by at least two experts from inside and outside Iraq.

* Research is first checked before being sent for review by anti-plagiarism using the third parity program.

*Authors must provide all data sources used in the research.

Duties and Responsibilities of Publishers

1. CBEJ is committed to ensuring that editorial decisions regarding submission of papers are final.

2. CBEJ promises to ensure that the decision to submit research is made solely on the basis of professional judgment and is not influenced by any commercial interests.

3. CBEJ is committed to maintaining the integrity of academic and research records.

4. CBEJ monitors the ethics of the editor-in-chief, members of the editorial board, reviewers, authors and readers.

5. CBEJ constantly checks for plagiarism and fraudulent data issues involved in submitted research.

6. cbej is always ready to post corrections, clarifications and revisions to its posts when needed.

Duties and responsibilities of editors

1. The journal editors should have full authority to reject/accept the paper.

2. The journal's editors must maintain the confidentiality of the submitted research under review until it is published.

3. The editor-in-chief shall decide on the submitted research, whether it has been published or not, together with the other editors and reviewers.

4. The journal editors must maintain the confidentiality of the reviewers.

5. Journal editors must disclose and try to avoid any conflicts of interest.

6. Journal editors shall maintain academic integrity and strive to meet the needs of readers and authors.

7. Journal editors must be willing to investigate plagiarism and fraudulent data issues and be willing to post corrections, clarifications, retractions, and apologies when needed.

8. Journal editors should limit themselves to intellectual content only.

9. Journal editors shall not disclose any information about submitted research to anyone other than the corresponding author, reviewers, and publisher, as applicable.

10. Unpublished material disclosed in the submitted research will not be used by the editor or members of the editorial staff for their own research purposes without the express written consent of the author.

Duties and responsibilities of arbitrators

1. The referees of the journal shall assist the editors in making a decision to publish the submitted papers.

2. Referees must keep the research they are invited to review confidential.

3. The reviewers shall provide timely comments to help the editors decide whether or not to publish the submitted papers.

4. Reviewers are obligated to treat research received for peer review as confidential and must not use information obtained through peer review for personal benefit.

5. The reviewers' comments on each paper must include technical, professional and objective.

6. Reviewers shall not review papers in which they find a conflict of interest with any authors, companies or institutions.

7. The arbitrators shall disclose and try to avoid any conflicts of interest.

Duties and responsibilities of the authors

1. Research should be presented and written according to sound rules and appropriate terminology.

2. Research must be submitted with the understanding that it has not been published elsewhere and is not currently under consideration by another previously published journal or any other publisher.

3. The first author responsible for ensuring that all other co-authors have agreed to publish the research.

4. To maintain the peer review system, authors are required to participate in a peer review process to evaluate research from others.

5. It is also the responsibility of the author to ensure that research papers issued by a specific institution are submitted with the necessary approval of the institution.

6. In order to submit research, the authors must allow the research to be edited to facilitate reading.

7. Authors are required to clearly identify who provided financial support for the conduct or preparation of the research and describe their role in any part of the work.

8. All authors agreed to allow the first author to communicate with the editorial board to review the edited research.

9. When the author(s) discover a major error or inaccuracy in their published work, it is the duty of the author to immediately notify the journal editor or publisher to withdraw or correct the paper.

10. All authors should know that research submitted under review or published with cbej is subject to check using plagiarism prevention software. Plagiarism is a serious violation of publishing ethics.

11. All authors must ensure that all authors have read the final submission checklist before submitting it to cbej.

Plagiarism policy:

Plagiarism is a serious violation. Plagiarism is the copying of ideas, text, data, and other creative work (such as tables, figures, and graphs) and presenting it as original research without proper citation. We define plagiarism as a condition in which a paper reproduces another work with at least 20% similarity and without citation.

If any evidence of plagiarism is found before the paper is accepted or after it is published, the author will be offered an opportunity to object. If the arguments are not satisfactory, the paper will be withdrawn and the author will be sanctioned from publishing the papers for a period to be determined by the editorial board.